When I am presented with a decision that isn't a no-brainer, I physically write a list of the good/bad that will happen if I do this; and also the good/bad if I don't.

Second, I ask myself whether, a year later, I will kick myself because I did or kick myself because I didn't.

After going through this, I feel comfortable with whatever decision I make, knowing that I did everything I could to make an intelligent one.

You might find this helpful, too.